Tampa Bay Lightning Game 27: at the New Jersey Devils
The Tampa Bay Lightning lost to the New Jersey Devils 3-2.
The Lightning lost with 38 seconds left in the game. It seems as if most of the goals that have been allowed by them have been in the last three minutes of the period. I know that the players keep track of how much time is left on the clock. Could it be them letting up thinking the period's almost over? It appears that way from the outside looking in, at least.
Some might blame the untimely penalties in this game for the loss, but I blame the lack of direction on the power play and the penalty kill. At this point, it looks like the guys are just thrown out there with a "go kill this any way you can" sort of mentality. There doesn't seem to be any kind of game plan for it. So much for Adam Oates stabilizing things, huh?
Generally speaking, though, there doesn't seem to be any on-ice direction with the team as a whole. Either they're not listening to the coaches and following their instructions, or there are no instructions to follow. Last night's game really reminded me of watching a junior hockey game. For those not familiar with junior hockey, a similar correlation would be going to a college football game and it seeming like a high school game. Talent isn't necessarily the issue, but lack of knowledge is.
27 games in, I see three thing going wrong with this team, and they're all from a coaching perspective. One, Rick Tocchet has no patience. He's looking for a quick fix to get the team going. Which is why no one played on the same line for long in this game. I think every forward took a turn at every single forward position, and played with every single other forward, over the course of the game.
The quick fix method just doesn't work. Athletes are creatures of habit - as are we all. How can any hockey player get comfortable with their linemates if they change all the time? How can they develop a good understanding of their linemates' abilities if they don't get to play with them for very long? They can't. So of course the players are just going to wing it and hope for the best.
And do you know what I find interesting? In all the time that Martin St. Louis and Vincent Lecavalier have been struggling to score goals, how often have Marty and Vinny actually played together this season? We all know that they have chemistry together - the last few years have more than demonstrated that. So why overlook the obvious and have them play on the same line to get them both going?
Another thing that I've noticed going wrong with this team is a lack of structure. As in, plays and game-situation scenarios. As far as I can tell, there aren't any. There is no official play book. They just sort of make things up on the ice as they go along.
The last thing that I've notice, which I've already mentioned before, is a lack of emphasis on playing a complete game. I'm not talking about playing 60 minutes. I'm talking about playing both offensively and defensively. The focus has clearly been on offense, while little attention has been given to playing defensively.
The forwards only play defense if they think about it - or if they see a need to while on the ice. Like when both of the defensemen are cheating into the zone for an offensive chance, and the forwards see that and back them up at the blue line. Which happens all the time - and it really shouldn't. That's just a complete lack of communication from the bench right there.
The defensemen in general look as if they've been completely neglected by the coaching staff at this point. They don't play games as if they don't know what's expected of them. They just sort of go along with the flow and hope for the best. Again, no on-ice game structure.
The bottom line is that it appears as if the coaches are all winging this. Which is understandable since most of them are new to their roles. The unfortunate part about it is that they're not flexible enough to fix things on the fly. Tocchet changes things up from game to game, sure, but is unable to change it up during the course of a single game. He sticks to the game plan for the entire game instead of abandoning something that doesn't work midway through.
The next game is tonight at home against the New York Islanders. Game time is 7:30 pm. The game thread opens at 7 o'clock for those interested in participating. Stop in if you're not going to the game - it's a good time.
In Lou We Trust [SB Nation New Jersey Devils Site]
Lightning vs Devils SB Nation coverage
6 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
Blame The Coach?
As you already know John, I respectfully disagree with you. I don’t believe the coaches are to blame and I can’t be critical of them without knowing what they are working on, on a daily basis. You’re right, players are “creatures of habit” and when bad things surface, a coach must try new things and switch things up, so not to allow these bad things to become habits. The coaching staff doesn’t play! The ultimate onus falls to the players. They are men who have made hockey their entire lives. They know how to play.
I’ve coached hockey for some 28 years (not on an NHL level) and I have never had nor seen an “official play book.” In fact, Scotty Bowman (certainly in the discussion of best hockey mind ever) once told me that “fancy plays don’t work in the NHL. Tell your boys to go out and play hockey the best that they can.” The coaches always get the blame because you can’t fire the team.
This team, simply isn’t as good as many think.The talent is not there. You can’t blame the coaches for that. Look to the front office for that, but most of all, look to the players themselves to find the biggest reason that the team is not playing well.
Thanks John. Great post!
WB Philp
Well, actually, it was my post, but that’s alright. It’s the coaches’ jobs to get the most out of their players, and the coaches aren’t. What I’ve seen so far this season is completely disorganized, and that’s not the players’ fault.
I’ll agree that the players are responsible as well, but at what point do you stop blaming the players and blame the coaches?
Raw Charge, an SBN Tampa Bay Lightning community. Calling shotgun in the clown car.
by Cassie McClellan on Dec 5, 2009 2:54 PM EST up reply actions
Sorry Cassie!
Sorry Cassie! I had John on the brain…sounds like a disease doesn’t it? If the players play poorly, you will have nothing to worry about because the coaches will get the blame. That’s just the way it works. Players at this level must be held accountable 100% of the time. I feel the coach should be scrutinized too, but not nearly to the extent that the players should be.
You mention the disorganization. What would coach Cassie do that you are certain that Tocchet isn’t?
WB Philp
by LightningShout on Dec 6, 2009 3:30 AM EST up reply actions
First thing I would do would be to make sure everyone knew what their roles were on the team. Then I’d make sure that everyone knew what everyone else’s roles were on the team. Make sure they’re all on the same page. After that, I’d make sure the defense wasn’t being treated like the red-headed stepchild that they have been and integrate them into the overall team dynamic. They’ve been left out in the cold with no direction, and that needs to end. Then I’d stabilize the forward lines by making sure that people know who they’ll be playing with, as well as keep lines together for a while. And on top of that, figure out a more coherent penalty kills system that actually works.
Is that enough? Or do you want more? ;o)
Raw Charge, an SBN Tampa Bay Lightning community. Calling shotgun in the clown car.
by Cassie McClellan on Dec 6, 2009 1:22 PM EST up reply actions
You have more information than I do
Cassie. I think you may be confusing what you “think” the coaches are or are not doing and what is actually going on in practices. It is hard for me to believe that the coaching staff is not preaching or doing the things that you mentioned. My reach into the Lightning locker room is limited, but I do talk with some insiders and I believe these issues that you mention are stressed and being worked on, but the players are the ones that must carry out the plan. I can tell you that I ’know" that the defense is not being treated as the “red-headed step child.” You really must not trust veteran defensive specialist, Assistant Coach Rick Wilson and his abilities.
All in all I think your observations are good and valid, but I think the players must be blamed for poor performance unless you “really” have information that the coaches are “ignoring” certain areas and groups of players.
WB Philp
Again, that’s very true. But the coaches need to present a coherent message in order for the players to execute it. Frankly, we can keep going around and around on this and never agree – and that’s okay. I’m just trying to get people to look at another view of the same situation. It’s easy to blame the players, and easiest of all to blame the stars. But that’s not necessarily the entire story, nor is it ever really all that simple.
Raw Charge, an SBN Tampa Bay Lightning community. Calling shotgun in the clown car.
by Cassie McClellan on Dec 8, 2009 6:13 AM EST up reply actions





















