The question that always comes to mind when thinking of the Lady Byng Memorial Trophy is this - is it a compliment or an insult for a hockey player to be nominated and/or win this award? Maybe a little of both? Discuss. There's no doubt that St. Louis was probably the best player for the Lightning this season. He certainly deserves something for all of the stitches in his face and all of the grief that he, and his teammates, endured. So is this a bright spot this season?