Raw Charge: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
New Blog: Once A Metro covering Red Bull New York!

Mike Smith and the Lightning goaltending situation

Goaltender Mike Smith, the Lightning's #1 goalie,  ended up playing  through the effects of Post Concussion Syndrome in December 2008, aggravated things in early January 2009, and has been recovering from this since February.  This you know. 

And now, with June only a matter of days away, we report Smith is still not skating.  He's improving from what General Manager Brian Lawton stated publicly:

"... the last report on the medical side was there is no reason he won't be 100 percent, and he's 100 percent in all his normal activities in life and just starting to ramp up his training."

There is much context on the improvements are missing.  Oh, for sure, he is not feeling the effects as much as before (which is good) but is he able to work out much at all?  He's "just begining to ramp up his training" leaves a lot to wonder about.

With coach Rick Tocchet's plan for a strenuous training camp to make sure his team is in condition for the long and grueling season, one has to wonder if the Bolts have started to formulate a backup plan if Mike is not ready to go?

Karri Ramo -- who played admirably through his trial-by-fire in the latter part of the 2008-09 campaign -- is a Restricted Free Agent.  Mike McKenna, who Rick Tocchet publicly called "a minor league goalie", is also an RFA...  That leaves prospects Riku Helenius and Dustin Tokarski as the only signed goalies in the system at this point.  Tokarski was playing in Juniors this past season while Helenius had stints in the ECHL, AHL and with the Lightning.

We've also noted that Edmonton Oil King's goalie Torrie Jung is Lightning property and Jung wowwed the CHL with his performance during the 1st round of the WHL playoffs.  But again, he is unsigned and will go back into the draft if the Bolts do not sign him by June 1st.

In all three cases with Helenius, Tokarski and Jung, they are largely inexperienced at the NHL level.  Of the five healthy goalies that the Lightning own the rights to, Ramo is the only one that could be looked at as experienced (with 48 NHL games under his belt in three seasons).

Suffice it to say, the Lightning are putting all their eggs in one basket if they solely hope that Smith is ready to go by the season start.  They are also doing so if they let Jung go back into the draft in favor of Tokarski.  Much like Major  League Baseball and pitching, you can never have too much goaltending talent at your disposal. 

There will be quite a few unrestricted free agent netminders in the off season, but who the Lightning will chase - or if, and how they will serve - is a big question.  There's also been rumor speculation revolving around big names and big talents. Both in trade speculation and free agent speculation, you have to wonder what kind of message this sends to the rest of those on the depth chart...  But it's a message that should be sent:  that the starting goalie position is up for grabs as Smith proves he has recovered.

And competition for such a vital position as goaltender is a good thing.  As was said earlier, you can never have too much goaltending talent in the system.  It creates a pleasant complication that helps address other shortcomings of the team through the trade market later on down the road.  The Bolts need to be wise and embrace this, rather than hoping that Smith suffers no setbacks and is 100 percent at the time Camp starts.  It's too big a gamble, much like leaving the possibility of Smith's return during last season as open-ended.  Why rush it?

Why risk it?

0 recs  |  Comment 0 comments

Story-email Email Printer Print

Comments

Display:

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

SB Nation's Tampa Bay Lightning community.
Start posting about the Lightning »

Join SB Nation and dive into communities focused on all your favorite teams.

Connect_with_facebook

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recent FanPosts

New-avatar-163307_small
Season Ticket season is here: Reductions and locked prices
Small
Two Goalies
Nicu_xmaswalls-2_small
Last Nights Game VS Atlanta
Nicu_xmaswalls-2_small
If I Were Brian Lawton
Jcow3_small
Raw Charge Presents: Nickname That Player!
Nicu_xmaswalls-2_small
pathetic
Stick_and_puck_small
Lightning Make Coaching Changes. How Will It End?
Stick_and_puck_small
Off Topic (sort of): Hockey Players at Midnight (and no, it's not what you might think...)
New-avatar-163307_small
Off Topic: Sixth Blogging Anniversary
S7302085_small
Report: Hawks Interested In Meszaros

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >

28 - 28 - 12

Lost 1

Featured Poll

Poll
Should Martin St. Louis be considered a Hart Trophy candidate?

  73 votes | Results

Raw Charge on the Web

Raw Charge

Promote Your Page Too



Eastern Conference Teams Blog Directory

SBNation.com Recent Stories

Edmonton Oilers second round pick Anton Lander, from Sweden, speaks to reporters at the 2009 NHL entry draft  in Montreal Saturday, June 27, 2009. (AP Photo/The Canadian Press, Ryan Remiorz) link

An Interview With Oilers Prospect Anton Lander

Washington Capitals' Alex Ovechkin (8), from Russia, shakes hands with Pittsburgh Penguins' Sidney Crosby (87) following Game 7 of an NHL hockey second-round playoff series, Wednesday, May 13, 2009, in Washington. The Penguins won 6-2. (AP Photo/Bruce Bennett, Pool) link

A Statistical Look At The NHL's MVP Race

Tampa Bay Lightnings' Ryan Malone (12) celebrates a goal in the third period of an NHL hockey game against the New York Islanders at Nassau Coliseum in Uniondale, N.Y., Monday, Dec. 21, 2009. The Lightning won 4-2. (AP Photo/Paul J. Bereswill)

Ryan Malone Undergoes Surgery, Expected To Miss 10-To-14 Days

More from SBNation.com >

eXTReMe Tracker

Managing Editors

New-avatar-163307_small John Fontana

Dscf0030-50_-crop_small Cassie McClellan

Writing Staff

Small Vancity Canuck

Moderators

Stick_and_puck_small TB_hockey_fan