Raw Charge: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
New Blog: The Nova Blog for Villanova Fans!

How do you restore faith in the franchise?

It is as simple as this. Fans trust Vinny Lecavalier a great deal, and they don’t trust the new ownership at all.

Around here, Lecavalier is not only the face of a franchise, he is the faith. In the chaos of a season, he is the reason to keep watching.

He is the reason to think things might eventually get good again.

--Gary Shelton, St. Petersburg Times, 01-14-2009

Martin-sullen_medium

Let me try to give you some of the names that have been moved by the Lightning in one way or another this past year: John Tortorella, Dan Boyle, Brad Lukowich, Filip Kuba, Alexandre Picard, Nick Tarnasky, Jay Feaster, Shane O'Brien, Michel Oullet, Matt Carle, Janne Niskala, Barry Melrose, Radim Vrbata, Jussi Jokinen, Steve Eminger, Jamie Heward, Olaf Kolzig, Mark Recchi.

Fired, traded, tossed, didn't pass muster, etc, etc, etc...  These are just the subtractions and doesn't include the additions of the rampant change at 401 Channelside Drive.  With each transaction, there is an accompanying story to which we could delve into.  A chapter in the grand novel that was the Lightning's 2008-09 season. 

But there's a subtext that can't be seen in any of these stories - of acquisitions, of failures, of knee-jerk reactions and what not.  That story is a story of faith.  A faith that existed with the five year build of former ownership that produced a championship and a competitive team.  It earned respect and loyalty from the fan base (even if the grumbles and cat-calls were mounting at the end of the Palace Sports reign).

That - the faith - is missing right now.  It doesn't seem evident.  It doesn't seem truly there, even with access to ownership again and again and again through forums and other means to get a clearer picture of OK Hockey's plan (such as May 11th's public forum at Times Palace).  Trust in doing the right thing seems missing.

And why? 

I've actually been wrestling with that for the last half hour...  And for most of the day for that matter.  I've been trying to figure out just what would bring back trust in management, faith that the team is moving forward toward long-term competitiveness and respectability again. 

If you go back to the listed transactions at the start of this article, the stories of each subtraction tend to be riddled with reasons why the faith has disappeared:  The moves, and fallout from those moves, have tended to be along the lines of cold.  It went further than the fact that sports are a business and do what's best for the business.  They've dallied into the impulsive while meandering through the bizarre.

The impulsive does not inspire trust -- it inspires caution. 

The bizarre only inspires faith that the next action may very well one-up the last in it's strangeness.

The only stability and consistency for the fans to revel in at this juncture are the long-time standard bearers of the team.  As Gary Shelton's quote from January suggests, the fans have more faith and trust in the abilities of Vincent Lecavalier than management.  This is also true for Martin St. Louis, as that advertisement suggests.  We've grown to know, respect, and admire these players.  We have seen the proof of their greatness and we find comfort in their abilities.

In contrast, we're being told "The Plan is in Place" by a group who has shown no consistency.  Actions speak louder than words, and those actions of this past season have not inspired trust...

The transactions, personnel moves both publicly and privately, the plan and blueprint are lacking one key cog - one key principle - that has to drive fans year in and year out.  It's a universal truth in sports and must be at the forefront once again for the Lightning, as it was in the not-so-distant past, before the Cup... 

How do you restore faith in the franchise?  With hope.

By the end of the 2000-2001 season, the Lightning had done just that under general manager Rick Dudley.  It's long term future was promising with the likes of Brad Richards, Fredrik Modin, Pavel Kubina, St. Louis and Lecavalier on the team.  The addition of Nikolai Khabibulin late in the season would further the idea the Bolts were ready to compete...  Hell, how many Lightning fans can recall Khabibulin's introduction to Tampa Bay?  That public press-conference erupted in cheers and chants of "Nikolai!"

Of course, there would be more additions and subtractions from that team before everything was said and done, including Dudley's departure from the Bolts and the hiring of Feaster and Tortorella...  But the fact is that hope arrived in 2000-01 even if the team that season still was atrocious.  And it wasn't through the promise of greatness from one single player,  but of a core of talented players that were untouchable.

The plan that OK Hockey needs to sell the fans on is why to be hopeful.  And you can't tell the fan to do so -- you need to show it on ice and through the actions of the franchise itself.  Big name, big ticket transactions may earn headlines, but it doesn't secure the competitiveness of the team.  That, if nothing else, should have been learned this past season.

An open rapport with the fans is great, but you don't need the glitz and glamor of Hollywood in these sessions.  What you need is only to be savvy people and businessmen, listening to your customers and understanding their concerns.  Not necessarily letting the mob control the direction of the team, but at least acknowledge just what the biggest concerns are.

Most importantly, hope might sooner be had for the fanbase with experience from those in charge.  It's an asset to have an experienced and versed executive to help out those new to the business of running a pro sports franchise and arena.   You need only look to St. Petersburg and the model Stuart Sternberg put into place with the Tampa Bay Rays franchise: rounding out inexperienced but eager staff with career baseball executive Gerry Hunsicker. 

Hiring someone like that, someone experienced and with renown to share in oversight responsibilities would go a long way to restoring confidence in this franchise.

Confidence, after all, does inspire faith...

And who knows, if the Bolts hold fast in what is being marked as one of the deepest drafts in years, use their selections wisely...  Well, hope for a better tomorrow and the overall future of the franchise is not that far out of reach.

0 recs  |  Comment 7 comments |

Story-email Email Printer Print

Comments

Display:

Faith and honoring contracts

It’s hard to do this now, as management has already made it’s bed and needs to lay in it with thanks to last off season and it’s dealings with Dan Boyle, but honoring contracts and no-trade clauses instead of publicly being open to offers for Lecavalier and others would go a long way.

But the news that Lawton was scouting prospect Matt Duchene in the OHL playoffs – a Center – seems counter to building faith that the team won’t move Vinny.

The Raw Charge -- the Tampa Bay Lightning weblog at SB Nation.

by John Fontana on May 5, 2009 5:33 PM EDT reply actions   0 recs

Earning trust is easy.

Win.

Nothing else will work. Not anything they say, not even an ownership change.

by Resolute on May 5, 2009 7:38 PM EDT reply actions   0 recs

Win doesn't ALWAYS build trust

I had that thought go through my head at one point today that the real answer was to win — but winning curing all ills is not always the truth. Sometimes they cause more ills than you realize because styles change with raised expectations.

But winning would make embarrassment from ownership more tolerable.

The Raw Charge -- the Tampa Bay Lightning weblog at SB Nation.

by John Fontana on May 5, 2009 9:06 PM EDT up reply actions   0 recs

Good article, well written.

IMO- you can start building faith by knocking off the revolving door (ala Dudley- chances are some of his moves had to be good based on the shear number of them). It took Feaster coming in here and calming things down and giving guys a chance to win a championship. If you trade for a guy (Carle among others), there’s probably a good reason. Just because he doesn’t perform right away doesn’t mean it was a mistake and you need to move him for pennies on the dollar. That’s ridiculous. Let these guys build some chemistry. Let the fans get to know them. They certainly aren’t going to put butts in seats by moving guys just as fans begin to like them. The only guys we fans really have a vested interest in right now are Vinny, Marty, maybe Prospal, perhaps Ranger, and probably Mike Smith. The rest we just don’t know.

by TampaFL on May 6, 2009 9:21 AM EDT reply actions   0 recs

In Defense of Dudley

I’m going to go back to a Jacques Demers quote from 1999 that he supposedly told Rick: “There’s nothing. The cupboard’s bare”. Dudley would later say he was out to acquire “assets” – and he was. In some deals, a vital, long term cog was picked up (Gratton to Buffalo for Wayne Primeau, Brian Holzinger and this defensive prospect named Cory Sarich). Thena gain, in other deals (the 1999 first round pick) it would turn into a revolving door of nothing (The pick for more picks (assets) from the Canucks, then Dan Cloutier and Niklas Sundstrom from the Rags along with more picks, and then Niklas Sundstrom to San Jose for other assets, much later Clouch to Vancouver for Adrian Aucoin, who would even LATER be dealt to the Isles for Kristian Kudroc, would would go no where).

In essence, even with a revolving door he was rebuilding a team that had nothing in the system. And some of those assets would be used to pick up Khabibulin in 2000-01.

Stability matters though and the last year has only reigned volatility on the team, comings and goings by way of transactions, injuries, and taking-my-ball-and-going-home type antics. The Carle situation was a knee-jerk reaction and the Melrose situation (and I am no fan of the Mullet – so I feel weird defending him) was the exact same thing.

Instead of bringing stuff in, the volatility has been spreading stuff around without really adding depth or long term impacts to the club – not positive ones at least.

BTW – Prospal is a fan favorite – even if he’s left the club twice. Paul Ranger has been growing with the fanbase as well. Ryan Craig and Evegeny Artyukhin have been Lightning property as long as Ranger and both have their niche (I see a lot of love for Artoo but Ryan Craig has gotten lost int eh shuffle).

The Raw Charge -- the Tampa Bay Lightning weblog at SB Nation.

by John Fontana on May 6, 2009 11:05 AM EDT up reply actions   0 recs

As I said, with the shear number of moves Dudley made, some of them have to work out. Same will probably be said of the current regime. We also picked up defensive prospect Ty Wishart who might be good in the trade that got us Carle. The problem is they gave up Boyle and later traded Carle for rejects like Eminger and Downie (later moving Eminger for the even worse Noah Welch- seriously? We wind up with Wishart, Downie and Welch for Dan freakin Boyle?) Maybe Wishart is the next Cory Sarich. But probably for someone else cause this front office will trade him before next season.

My opinion of the Melrose situation- stupid to hire him. Even stupider to fire him weeks into a season.

I know Prospal is a fan favorite, but he is amazingly consistently inconsistent. Luckily, next year should be his “on” year. Artyukhin ticked a lot of fans of when he left for Russia, but you are right, he still has his fans. Personally, I am a huge fan of Ryan Craig, but he has no business playing center in the NHL. Really guys? You send down the perfectly servicable Chris Gratton (and later lose him for nothing) so that Craig can play 4th line center? Really?

by TampaFL on May 6, 2009 1:52 PM EDT up reply actions   0 recs

There were more trades for the sake of trades though

Wishart was picked up in the Boyle deal, right (and we lost another NHL caliber D-man in Brad Lukowich in that trade)… But what did we do with the ever valuable first round selection we also got in that trade? Dealt it to Ottawa (with another prospect Defenseman in Alex Picard and Filip Kuba) for Andrej Meszaros?

To give management the benefit of the doubt, you can say they are also picking up assets… But when deals like that dominate more so than the Richard Petiot deal or the Matt Lashoff trade (those guys got my attention), it doesn’t look like acquiring assets but instead — warm bodies. The Welch deal is a great example: They didn’t just pick up a lower tier prospect, they also picked up a special UFA group to be.

The Carle knee-jerk deal really seemed demented: Steve Downie was brought in? Downie? Even if Eminger was not the greatest on D, he was an NHL experienced defenseman compared to revolving door on defense that ended the season.

The Raw Charge -- the Tampa Bay Lightning weblog at SB Nation.

by John Fontana on May 6, 2009 2:27 PM EDT up reply actions   0 recs

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

SB Nation's Tampa Bay Lightning community.
Start posting about the Lightning »

Join SB Nation and dive into communities focused on all your favorite teams.

Connect_with_facebook

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recent FanPosts

New-avatar-163307_small
Season Ticket season is here: Reductions and locked prices
Small
Two Goalies
Nicu_xmaswalls-2_small
Last Nights Game VS Atlanta
Nicu_xmaswalls-2_small
If I Were Brian Lawton
Jcow3_small
Raw Charge Presents: Nickname That Player!
Nicu_xmaswalls-2_small
pathetic
Stick_and_puck_small
Lightning Make Coaching Changes. How Will It End?
Stick_and_puck_small
Off Topic (sort of): Hockey Players at Midnight (and no, it's not what you might think...)
New-avatar-163307_small
Off Topic: Sixth Blogging Anniversary
S7302085_small
Report: Hawks Interested In Meszaros

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >

28 - 28 - 12

Lost 1

Featured Poll

Poll
Should Martin St. Louis be considered a Hart Trophy candidate?

  72 votes | Results

Raw Charge on the Web

Raw Charge

Promote Your Page Too



Eastern Conference Teams Blog Directory

SBNation.com Recent Stories

New Jersey Devils' Zach Parise celebrates his goal with Jamie Langenbrunner, right, as Boston Bruins' Matt Hunwick, left, looks on during the first period of an NHL hockey game Monday, March 15, 2010 in Newark, N.J. The Devils beat the Bruins 3-2. (AP Photo/Bill Kostroun)

Devils Hold Off Bruins Late Surge; Win 3-2

New York Islanders General Manager Garth Snow, right, poses for a photograph with Scott Gordon, head coach of the New York Islanders during a news conference Wednesday, Aug. 13, 2008  in Uniondale, N.Y. Gordon, the reigning American Hockey League Coach of the Year with the Providence Bruins, is the 14th head coach in franchise history. He has agreed to a multi-year contract with the Islanders. (AP Photo/Frank Franklin II) link

Three Years In, Islanders Showing Garth Snow's Impact

FILE -- This is an April 9, 2009, file photo showing Dallas Stars center Mike Modano warming up before facing the Colorado Avalanche in an NHL hockey game in Denver. Modano knows he's one of the old guys now, but the 39-year-old Dallas Stars standout is eager to play his way onto one more Olympic team.(AP Photo/David Zalubowski, File) link

Mike Modano To Miss Time After Emergency Appendectomy

More from SBNation.com >

eXTReMe Tracker

Managing Editors

New-avatar-163307_small John Fontana

Dscf0030-50_-crop_small Cassie McClellan

Writing Staff

Small Vancity Canuck

Moderators

Stick_and_puck_small TB_hockey_fan