Exploitation, self promotion, and pro-athletes online
Twitter has a lot of celebrities on it, basking in additional attention paid to them from the masses while reporting mundane things in their lives. Fans hang on their words and their news about every minor or major happening, helped along by the link of said celebrity to the medium in which they work: movies, politics, television, and sports.
Of course, with all of these real celebrities on Twitter, there are plenty of imposters as well, who try to accomplish one of several things: To pay homage to the person, to satirize them/mock them, or to capitalize off of the famous name and promote themselves a little more.
Members of the Tampa Bay Lightning are not exempt from this. While team executives such as former owner Oren Koules, Angelina Lawton, and former team captain Dave Andreychuk have official Twitter accounts, there are imposters that have popped up during the course of the season under different player and staff names.
This faking-it epidemic goes much further than just the Tampa Bay Lightning. You can find fake player accounts devoted to members of any team in the league and with most any sport for that matter. Even prospects that have yet to turn pro can be subjected to this. John Tavares, last year's #1 overall draft selection, was victim of an imitator during the lead up to the 2009 NHL entry draft. The fake Tavares kept reporting about the whirlwind leading up to the June 26th draft event, including the false announcement he would nto be the #1 selection overall.
You have to wonder just how players combat this. What can be done? Who is going to protect them when something like this is going on? They're busy enough with their own lives and seldom have little interest in actually using Twitter, or Facebook, or any other social application that is not direct contact with people.
Lightning communications director Bill Wickett admitted that the Bolts don't have a policy in place at this time, "We do acknowledge that there may be a need to start looking out for our players and staff in the future."
Wickett also pointed out that, "NHL Security department gets involved if needed to help protect all of our players as necessary."
Ultimately, legal responsibility for protecting a player's name and reputation falls to their agent or personal management, t he guys who represent them in contract negotiations with teams or in other business facets. Sure, a team could step up to protect the identity of one of its stars - but an agent worth his salt is going to protect the identity and reputation of his client if and when a line is crossed or a potential opportunity is robbed by an impostor.
But how many agents actually make it a point to be proactive about this?
Jim DeLorenzo, Vice President of Octagon Sports Agency's Digital Division, explained that Octagon has no official policy regarding social media.
"However, my advice to athletes is that one of the best ways to combat impersonation is to join the service where there is an issue and announce your presence," DeLorenzo wrote in an email. "Also, both Facebook and Twitter have impersonation policies in place that allow athletes to have the fake profiles removed. In my experience, Facebook and Twitter have been very responsive when contacted on impersonation issues."
What's the big deal anyway, though? Besides hijacking a famous person's identity online and treating it as just all in good fun, it's a business hazard for the player/person-of-note that is being imitated. In January 2010, comScore reported that Twitter brought in 75 million unique visitors (per this TechCrunch article with graph ). With that many eyes reading 140-character messages, it has the strength to take a message and spread it with speed among a massive audience.
While a lot of people only see Twitter as someone spreading mundane things to entertain the masses, it does have its viral uses in reporting things as they happen, earning attention to situations of note, and can be a means of promoting an event or a cause that a person with a direct audience (or following) holds dear to them.
All this Twitter talk does not even address the 300+ million worldwide users on Facebook and the potential reach that it provides. Some personalities are more involved with the more established social networks than with Twitter. Current Lightning captain Vincent Lecavalier already has a profile with the network (as well as on MySpace), and the foundation that shares his name is active in promoting his causes.
On the other hand, there are six different personal profiles that claim to be Steven Stamkos. We're not talking about "fan pages", which are designed for fans of a person or product, but presenting themselves as Stamkos himself.
Martin St. Louis has five.
Back to Twitter, they're very forthcoming with this and make it clear that "name squatting" is against Twitter's terms of use. Impersonation, however...:
Twitter users are allowed to create parody, commentary, or fan accounts. Please refer to Twitter's Parody Policy for more information about these accounts. Accounts with the clear intent to confuse or mislead may be permanently suspended.
That parody policy gives clear rules on how to operate and put you in the clear. As for what players and agents can do to secure their identity on Twitter, there are clear rules on how to stop impersonation accounts .
Twitter is also now implementing a verification policy, which makes it clear how you can tell if an account is that of the famous person it claims to be (and steps a player or celebrity can take to become verified).
As a fan on the Internet, you're free to follow the name of someone famous, as well as whomever you want to on any social network site. But to follow someone real is better than to follow an opportunist trying to capitalize off a famous person's reputation. You're empowering an impostor when you follow the fake.
Make sure you do your homework and research just who you are adding. After you verify, then you can trust. Players and teams can do only so much to deal with impostors. It's ultimately up to you and your judgment.
For the record, we checked in with Lightning media relations manager Brian Breseman and asked him for the verified accounts for players and staff with the Tampa Bay Lightning. He stressed the one official account with the team as the verified source for the Lightning on Twitter: @tblightning.
2 recs |
12 comments
|
Comments
excellent piece, John, and rec'd
Its really something important to get out there, because you’re dealing with a lot of fans that truly believe they are following the actual player. I was duped into following “@zparise”, and later found out it was not Zach Parise.
Now, how long did it take you to tag that post? Thats quite a list of tags…
Oh, and, uh…follow me on Twitter!
On the Forecheck: a blog that's more productive than a Predator power play!
Follow me on Twitter
This is a problem, but there’s little to be done about it. As a Devil’s employee myself, the phony Zach account was brought to our attention, but it’s like, who cares? As John suggested, Zach has little time or interest in social media. He has a Facebook, but doesn’t accept strangers’ requests. Neither does Marty Brodeur have a twitter, despite several twitter accounts that claim to be him.
In order to combat this, we have to contact a half a dozen people who have more important things to do. As long as the impostor isn’t dragging Zach or Marty’s names through the mud, there is really no urgency to make the effort.
If Andrew Peters ever plays again it will be too soon.
by LangsForPres on Mar 4, 2010 3:59 PM EST up reply actions 1 recs
Interesting
Never thought about this before since I don’t have a Twitter account and personally not interested in reading self-centered, vacuous nuggets such as “Am break dancing in WalMart to Hall and Oates.” But, really, this is a problem for people whose name has been usurped. Twitter has unenforceable rules with “who cares” penalties. The web is indeed a two-edged sword.
It's ongoing..
Way back in 1998 when logged into my first chatroom, the very first person I ever talked to online told me he played for some (can’t remember which) baseball team. I didn’t buy it but he kept insisting, and I have a feeling if the guy had a more convincing vehicle such as twitter I might have fallen for it. It’s scary to think what some of these name squatters’ ulterior motives may be.
by Melissa Reynolds on Mar 4, 2010 10:46 AM EST reply actions 1 recs
Excellent Thoughts
I’ll admit that I’m guilty of adding/friending celebs (In high school I friended 4 Jason Mraz’s on FB), in full knowledge that it is a fake. To me, it’s humorous and juvenile—following the player, being a "friend" of the player, feeling like you know what’s in the back of the players head. In many cases, it’s an innocent way of hanging on every word a player "says."
However, I hadn’t thought about fake profiles being detrimental to the player’s career, even when it’s innocent. If that’s the reality, I’m glad to be rid of it. It’s good to see that FB and twitter are making good efforts/policies to protect celebrities from the PR damage that comes hand in hand with fake profiling, which will become more important as social networking continues to grow. It’s also good (in the case of TB), that the organization is making professional accounts to create a contrast between the real and the fakes.
In the end, players don’t need extra publicity because they’re already big enough. Informed of the reality, I’d rather not support a trend that is potentially damaging to a player’s career. It seems like the better thing to do is be respectful of the players privacy and personality.
"they’re big. they’ve got big man bodies." lovingthelightning.wordpress.com
by Meredith Qualls on Mar 4, 2010 12:24 PM EST reply actions
and seriously, the essay of tags?
"they’re big. they’ve got big man bodies." lovingthelightning.wordpress.com
by Meredith Qualls on Mar 4, 2010 12:24 PM EST up reply actions
Well researched and written
I’ve noticed some celebrities taking the time (and effort) to “verify” their Twitter accounts. But you are so right in saying that most don’t want to: 1. open their personal lives up to even more public scrutiny, and 2. take the extra time it needs to post such drivel as “used extra paper towels in the ladies’ room. woman next to me called me a paper waster.” I think you highlight some important security points. Agents, management and yes, teams, should pay extra attention to what’s floating around out there, even if it’s time-consuming. Better to spend the time trying to prevent damage, than spend it doing damage control.
MotleySu
by MotleySu on Mar 4, 2010 2:51 PM EST reply actions 1 recs
Thanks for the write-up
Those are some legit concerns. On the flip side, I believe you should have contacted DownGoesBrown, the fella behind last years “Brian Burke” fake twitter feed. It was funny, and CLEARLY a parody/satire. I think his perspective would have been a benefit to your article.
.... formerly "Tim" of StLouisGameTime.com
by CrossCheckRaise on Mar 5, 2010 8:47 PM EST reply actions 1 recs
That's actually a good point
I was considering contacting a few people. DGB’s stuff is clearly humorous and his reputation is for humor. It would have shown more objective to bring in his take (no one had suggested it to me while I was writing this).
9:12. Lights out. Raw Charge.
I hear ya
nothing’s worse than a great idea …. after you’ve already finished something, LOL
.... formerly "Tim" of StLouisGameTime.com
by CrossCheckRaise on Mar 6, 2010 2:01 PM EST up reply actions
An Athlete verification site
Just came across it: http://www.sportsin140.com/
9:12. Lights out. Raw Charge.






















