Raw Charge: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
Around SBN: SB Nation MMA Rankings for August 2010

Raised expectations breeding defensive doubts for Lightning

The perceived boogeyman for the Lightning, at this moment, is on the blueline.  It's a raving mess of inexperience, overage, inconsistency, etc, etc, etc. 

And the worst crime at all is, there is no sexy big-name acquisition to compliment the Simon Gagne move!  Ugh!  Steve Yzerman needs to get to work to remedy that situation, STAT!

...That, or fans need to lower expectations a little and let things work themselves out.

Star-divide

The Lightning depth chart on defense is deep enough not to be a cause for concern.  Besides the likes of Mattias Ohlund, Pavel Kubina, Victor Hedman, Mike Lundin, Brett Clark and Matt Smaby as a top six, there is Matt Lashoff, Vladmir Mihalik, Ty Wishart, Scott Jackson, and other young players ready to push for a roster spot and playing time. 

Of course, this does not ease concern of competence on defense. 

Last season, the defensive effort routinely resembled that of the Keystone Kops - players falling over each other and a lack of jelling, cohesion, and synchronization on coverage.  It highlighted flaws to whatever the plan was on defense, which were then exploited by opposing teams.  There were mental lapses and miscues.  Occasionally, the lax defensive effort left goaltenders Mike Smith and Antero Niittymaki fending for themselves.  All of this cost the team dearly in the end.

But one little issue here that is not getting much attention is the coaching aspect of last season's squad and the forthcoming 2010-11 team.  While Rick Tocchet and Rick Wilson were in charge behind the bench last season and responsible for the defensive effort - there had never been a moment where either coach had praise heaped upon them for improvements to the defensive game.

Enter Guy Boucher and his band of merry men from the Hamilton Bulldogs that will be in control for the Lightning from this point forward.  This isn't a unit put together by feuding GM and head coach that have different ideas for the team, this is a group of guys who have worked together and know the system they are going to employ.

This is a group that's already been part of the process remaking the team, who had a say when the Bolts signed Pavel Kubina and Brett Clark.  They're a coaching staff with a successful history on their side.

That's not to say Rick Wilson, as defense specialist for the Lightning, hadn't a history of success as an assistant on the Dallas Stars before he was hired last season.  Unfortunately, he found himself in the midst of a proverbial minefield when he joined the Tampa Bay staff: A rookie coach, a rookie GM, a mix-and-match defense...

And in the end, no clear system employed.  "Just go out there and stop guys" seemed to be the instruction from the powers-that-be.

What does this all have to do with the current defensive depth for the Bolts?  I want to see the unit under Boucher's rule before I want the Lightning to go out and try to revamp the defense again.  I'm not sold on trying to acquire a big-name defenseman, like Tomas Kaberle from the Toronto Maple Leafs, in order to beef up the name recognition on defense.  Kaberle's name has come up a few times in the past year as someone potentially linked to the Lightning as an answer on defense.

Why the need for a big ticket acquisition like that in the first place? 

Yes, the Lightning did lose a cog when it traded Matt Walker to the Philadelphia Flyers in the Simon Gagne trade.  While we've played up how much of a robbery that deal was, the fact is that the steady stay-at-home defenseman in "Tex" Walker, with a right-handed shot to boot, had some value to the club. 

Not enough value, however, to think the Lightning is in dire need to run out and find a replacement for him.

It may be the notion of contention by the club that seems to influence the idea that the defense needs help.  With the Gagne move, and the top-six offensive depth, there's the perceived need of the big name being added to the ranks of the blueline to even things out. 

And there's the forgotten sentiment that the Lightning aren't out to win the Stanley Cup this season...  They're going to compete, that's for sure, but the construction of this team is supposed to have an eye on the long-term for the club.  Not a short-term, quick-fix blueprint.

This doesn't mean that Steve Yzerman needs to be happy with the defensemen he has.  I'd just rather him see the actual talent and how they perform under Coach Boucher before moving to acquire someone else.

0 recs  |  Comment 5 comments |

Story-email Email Printer Print

Comments

Display:

John, great article. Two amplifying points, though, I think bear emphasis.

First, what we know of Coach Boucher’s system (at least as it was in Hamilton) was a high-pressure team effort. By that I mean the defensive responsibility will be spread over all five skaters, rather than just the two traditional d-men. That may be why the team’s management is going for the players they are pursuing.

The second point is purely economical. This off-season we’ve seen d-men go for a premium, in stark contrast to years previous. It may be a case of the market has priced us out of the d-men we’d like (see also Martin, Volchenkov, etc.)

Your point is a very good one, though. With all the splash the front office has made, we as fans need to temper our expectations. Rome wasn’t built in a day, and neither are Stanley Cup championship-caliber teams.

by MTBoltFan on Jul 23, 2010 2:44 PM EDT reply actions  

Part one of yoru concern is where I’m putting faith in coaching and Boucher’s other aspect of coaching: He caters tot eh player, not to the sytem alone.

Ultimately we’ll know if personnel is an issue as we move forward. I just don’t think it’s as big an issue right now as it’s being made out.

"Seen Cincuenta" -- 04.10.10 -- Raw Charge.

by John Fontana on Jul 23, 2010 3:31 PM EDT up reply actions  

Yes, great article.

I like what you pointed out about the emphasis on team defense in Boucher’s system, MTBF. Usually “swarm hockey” is a pejorative way of describing a team’s play, but if I remember correctly, Boucher indicated he believes in his team aggressively fore- and back-checking to force turnovers by getting more players to the puck than the opposing team. Up-tempo, I believe is the buzzword I keep hearing.

by Michael Gallimore on Jul 23, 2010 3:51 PM EDT reply actions  

Controlled, smarty, systematic aggression.

Boucher hasn’t gotten this far preaching reckless abandon. SO looking forward to tomorrowseason. :-)

by Michael Gallimore on Jul 23, 2010 3:53 PM EDT up reply actions  

Evaluate then adjust

I think there’s a good level of talent on the Bolts D and agree with John in that the coaches last season just threw them out there. Prior to last season Ohlund averaged over 7.5 goals a season during his 11 seasons, while playing less that 60 games 3 times during that span. Even though he won’t see major time on the PP, you still have to believe he can get 5 goals and 25 points, and play better d. During 09’ during the horrific final 3 months of the season Matt Smaby stood out as our best defenseman even playing a month or more with a broken foot, but a pair of concussions last year and an obvious rift with Tocchet rendered Matt inefective, when he did get the chance to play. Hadman and Lundin should continue to improve. Clark should bounce back from a rough second half last season and less expectation to carry the load. Kubina is a horse and will eat minutes. I hope he remebers his prowess on the PP from his previous stint with the Bolts. If we’re in the thick of the playoff race at the deadline, then you make a move for the final piece on d. Let’s see what Bouchr can do with the group first.

Don in St Pete

by Don in St Pete on Jul 23, 2010 8:38 PM EDT reply actions  

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

"The static cling that brings Tampa Bay Lightning fans together", SB Nation's Bolts community is your place for news, commentary and camaraderie.
Start posting about the Lightning »

Join SB Nation and dive into communities focused on all your favorite teams.

Connect_with_facebook

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recent FanPosts

Small
One more time
Lightning_stamkos_hockey_vc_2_small
Why not Bieksa?
New-avatar-163307_small
With the good comes the bad: Mount Suckmore nominations sought
Messin_around_by_maxgardner_small
A Downie / Kaberle Connection?
Vinnyfunny_small
Let’s Take the Preseason for a Spin
New-avatar-163307_small
St. Pete Times Forum and the Lightning Launch weekend
Small
Fat Tony's Eastern Conference Power Rankings
Small
Enough Offensive Depth?
Small
Push me I'll push you back!
Small
Fat Tony's Defensive Depth Chart.(TBL)

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >

Pages

Featured Poll

Poll
Should the Lightning play preseason exhibition games in Orlando in the future?

  38 votes | Results

Raw Charge on the Web

Wikio



Eastern Conference Teams Blog Directory


TOP 100 HOCKEY SITES

SBNation.com Recent Stories

PHILADELPHIA - MAY 16:  A fan of the Philadelphia Flyers holds up a sign reading "Next Goalie" behind goalie Carey Price #32 of the Montreal Canadiens in Game 1 of the Eastern Conference Finals during the 2010 NHL Stanley Cup Playoffs at Wachovia Center on May 16, 2010 in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania.  (Photo by Bruce Bennett/Getty Images)

Habs Finally Lock Up Carey Price, Sign Goalie To Two-Year Deal

National Hockey League commissioner Gary Bettman answers questions during a pre-game media availability before the Pittsburgh Penguins season opener against the New York Rangers in a NHL hockey game in Pittsburgh, Friday, Oct. 2, 2009. (AP Photo/Gene J. Puskar) +25 updates

Ultimatum? NHL Reportedly Threatens To Toss Out Kovalchuk, Luongo Deals Without NHLPA Concessions

Photo +1 updates

Report: Donald Fehr Hands NHLPA List Of Conditions On Becoming Union Leader

More from SBNation.com >

eXTReMe Tracker

Managing Editors

New-avatar-163307_small John Fontana

Dscf0010-50__small Cassie McClellan

Writing Staff

Small Dani Toth

Stick_and_puck_small TB_hockey_fan

Logo_small Meredith Qualls

Nolan01_small Nolan Whyte