Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
Around SBN: Devils Beat Rangers, Head To Stanley Cup Finals

Stammergeddon: Rumors, paranoia, and Tampa Bay sports

"He said what?!  And you believed it?  Why?  Why would I leave?  It's just starting to get exciting around here!"  (Photo by Jeff Gross/Getty Images)

With the start of the 2011 NHL free agency season, and young star Steven Stamkos entering restricted free agency (meaning he could be tendered an offer sheet from any of the 29 other clubs, though the Bolts had the right to match any offer he received), some Lightning fans were dead certain that Stamkos' days in Tampa were numbered, especially when renown rumor-mongers played up the idea that Stamkos wanted out.

All of this transpired, in part, because Steven wasn't signed before or by July 1st and there wasn't much tangible information about negotiations after July 1. It turned into end-of-days pandemonium ("Repent, repent!") And with the panic that ensued through the social networks and broader Internet, the age of Stammergeddon was born. Every day, every moment that Stamkos was not signed was another sign of the Stam-pocalypse.

Star-divide

Yet, Steven Stamkos himself would disclose after his signing to a new five-year contract on July 19th, that he and the club had agreed to financial terms in private early in the process. It was about extras and details that took time to iron out.

The whole length of the process was miniscule compared to other marquee restricted free agents, or even lesser known RFAs who have received qualifying offers from the team that holds their rights.

But there was not outright bedlam about Zach Parise being unsigned by the New Jersey Devils through August 4th; there is no panicked frenzy regarding the continued RFA status of Toronto Maple Leafs d-man Luke Schenn and Los Angeles Kings defenseman Drew Doughty (two other stars from the 2008 NHL entry draft).

In other words, there isn't an ongoing overreaction.

Tampa Bay sports fans seem to have heightened insecurity when it comes to these things. We're always on the verge of disaster by way of a trade, free-agent loss, contraction, relocation, or the latest Tampa Bay Buccaneer quarterback. Of course, the Bay area does have a history that's led to such paranoia. It's one of bad management decisions, head-scratching exploits, or outright stupidity.

Let's start with football where there was Buccaneer quarterback Doug Williams being forced out in favor of Jack "Throwin Samoan" Thompson. Then-owner Hugh Culverhouse was to blame, and not just for being a tightwad. His treatment of Williams would lead to Bo Jackson snubbing the Bucs in the NFL Draft after being selected 1st overall. Former NFL coaching great Bill Parcells left the Bucs at the proverbial altar. Twice (1993 and 2002), which dashed hopes for a time. And at current, fans look at the Glazer family seemingly investing more time and money in Manchester United than on their NFL team.

In hockey, the Lightning suffered the loss of Chris Gratton in 1997 after he signed an offer-sheet with the Philadelphia Flyers (and the fuzzy fax fiasco that followed it is one of the odder moments in team history). 11 years later, Dan Boyle was re-signed to a lengthy contract, only to be traded four months later out of spite by former owner Len Barrie.

Oh, and a decade-plus of Lecavalier-to-Montréal rumors. Can't forget that.

Being jerked around by Major League Baseball for years on end, and the Buccaneers threatening relocation in 1995-96 if the Community Investment Tax referendum didn't pass didn't help any, either.

Yeah, Tampa Bay sports fans have had their share of major ups-and-downs, but every fan from every team in pro sports can cite one or more instances that makes the fans anxious. Anxious, but not completely paranoid.

Watching on Twitter with people interacting in 140 characters, or on Facebook (without space constraints), too many were too quick to buy into rumors spawned from the fictitious authority that is Eklund. For the casual fan that treated his word as truth, you should know that Eklund's "reporting" is accurate less than 3.3% of the time. Lets not even try to gauge the accuracy of his imitators.

There was at least one local source that contributed to the hysteria too. Steve Duemig, the king-fish in Tampa Bay sports radio, decided to enlighten his Twitter followers (and hoist out-of-town fans hopes) by sharing the news of a threat of Philadelphia signing Stamkos.

When an authority of local sports-talk plays up hearsay, it's not going to squelch the hysterics.

Is paranoia really more rampant in Tampa Bay? Are we so insecure that we're confident the end is nigh? Are we so inexperienced with the hot stove of pro-sports that we can't just brush off the inane rhetoric from sources that thrive on creating news when there isn't any?

Actually, in that final question lies the answer. In this age of information, everything seems amplified. One vague statement by an official, a beat reporter, or even a blogger, soon becomes a game of telephone. The original statement gets warped as it's heard and repeated by others. While Twitter is a great gateway for news (and a great place to use as a sounding board), it's also ideal for the spread of misinformation with speed.

The craving for information on the Stamkos contract is what drove so many to jump at the rumors and panic. The same information moratorium led to wild speculation on Jeffrey Vinik's intentions before his purchase of the Tampa Bay Lightning in March 2010, as well as with who he would hire as GM and CEO.

Are Tampa Bay fans paranoid and insecure? Well, only when they overreact and become a bit too anxious. History and hearsay can easily lead fans of any team and any sport into a panic, and we're no exception as Stammergeddon has shown us.

It doesn't have to be this way, but it is the way of the hot stove. Overreacting doesn't help anyone in the end, but it is a great promotional tool for those whose livelihoods depend on it.

 

Raw Charge on Facebook @RawCharge

Comment 8 comments  |  0 recs  | 

Do you like this story?

Comments

Display:

Note

I cited Steve Duemig in this post and only linked to a comment on Raw Charge from June 24. Steve “protects” his tweets (it’s a private account) on Twitter and I could not link to any of his tweets about the subject directly.

Typing is an adventure, and reading should be, too!
Raw Charge.

by John Fontana on Aug 15, 2011 10:27 AM EDT reply actions  

Great post, John

Of course, this being my first experience with anything remotely like Stammergeddon, I have no touchstones for perspective on exactly how paranoid people got this summer. There was “Weber-geddon” over in Nashville, but it was different.* For one thing, we didn’t have the rest of the world telling us that the end was coming (Toronto and Philly fans, I’m looking at you.). The noise from outside BoltsNation over Stamkos was almost louder than the noise from inside. I do wonder how much Twitter, Facebook, and the rapidly growing hockey blogosphere amplified the din. Someone once said, “Hitting the refresh button on Twitter is the new nailbiting.”

*Funnily enough, in Nashville the most noise happened after the arbitration and not before, with the exception of a few spasms of panic when a quote would come out (or when it didn’t after people convinced themselves it would come at X point).

"I'm a firm believer that in life, if you're happy then happy things will happen for you."--Bernie Parent
Part Predator, part Lightning.

by CAustin on Aug 15, 2011 10:35 AM EDT reply actions  

Superb.

Two points as way of personal feeling:
1. Duemig is the reason I do not listen to 620AM at all except for Lightning games. I stopped listening to him after Game 1 against the Penguins. He actually had the gall to call out Roli and say the team wasn’t going anywhere if he was starting in net.
2. I’ve never lived anyplace where a major league city has radio broadcasts of a division rival and the home team (Yankees broadcasts on Tampa radio?). No wonder the Rays’ fan base is mediocre. Such a practice is unthinkable in any other city than Tampa.
3. People are naturally drawn to the big-name trades, and I think that’s the draw of some to HockeyBuzz. Sure, it’s complete garbage (flip of a coin is more accurate – E5), but the big names trading teams is always “sexy.”

"The Revolution will be complete when the language is perfect"
- Smith in Orwell's 1984

by MTBoltFan on Aug 15, 2011 12:45 PM EDT reply actions   1 recs

Thin skin

I don’t know if it’s paranoia but we (Tampa Bay) do not take criticism well. At least our media doesn’t especially, the papers. Every single time someone from another market has something to say about our teams, facilities of the area itself, especially if it’s negative, expect to see it re-printed in a prominent spot in at least one of our major dailies. I’ve never seen anything like it before. A perfect example is today’s (Tuesday, Aug 16) tbt*. The back cover (the front page of the sports section) and an entire page inside is devoted to an op-ed piece written by a New York Yankees fan (and St. Pete Times intern) about how Tropicana Field isn’t all that bad. And if you go to the Times web site, you can also find this headline today: “”http://www.tampabay.com/sports/baseball/rays/tampa-bay-rays-la-times-slams-rays-fans-doubleheader-numbers/1186171" target="new">L.A. Times slams Rays fans"
Like I said, I don’t know if that ties into the paranoia angle but it certainly speaks to a mindset that exists in this market.

by Clark J Brooks on Aug 16, 2011 2:24 PM EDT reply actions  

The typical Tampa Bay fan...

is the that guy who cheers for the Tampa Bay team as long as they are not playing (insert whatever city you want here) and says he does this because typical Tampa fans have no enthusiasm for Tampa teams.

Someone needs to tell that guy HE is the typical Tampa sports fan, as well as a heavily used and often recycled douche bag. Cheering for your “hometown” team does not make that guy loyal or special in Tampa. If that guy lived in Boston, New York, Chicago, Toronto, Montreal, San Diego, or anywhere else outside of Tampa, that guy might be unique. However, doing so in Tampa Bay, makes you a bandwagonner colostomy collector.

The reason why things like this get so much attention in Tampa is the spite that people who choose to live here carry because they don’t want to fully dive into and absorb the culture (or maybe they are and it’s a self fulfilling paradox at this point?). And I can’t stand the “that guy” speech of “my job made me move here”. If your former city was that frigging awesome, you’d have a job there no matter what. FACE IT, YOU LEFT, YOU SUCK, NO ONE LIKED YOU BACK “HOME”, AND BECAUSE OF YOUR DOUCHE BAGGERY NO ONE LIKES YOU HERE EITHER. These people love to hear about Tampa Bay teams losing big names from their teams because of that spite. It’s that simple. It’s that predictable.

"System Trumps Chumps" - Tampa t

by tankerkevo on Aug 16, 2011 6:35 PM EDT reply actions   2 recs

bandwagonner colostomy collector

That’s funny right there.

"The Revolution will be complete when the language is perfect"
- Smith in Orwell's 1984

by MTBoltFan on Aug 17, 2011 12:53 PM EDT up reply actions  

I think part of Stammergeddon is very Lightning specific

It must have been because the Lightning won a Stanley Cup, but ever since that happened the Canadian media has not been able to handle this team’s mere existence and/or competence. Every time it’s perceived that a player important to the team has any chance of being available (even if they aren’t), it’s just assumed we will donk that player off to either Toronto or Montreal in a trade where we get back 20 cents on the dollar.

It’s like hockey writers in the Great White North are threatened by there being a really good hockey team in Florida. For God’s sake, Atlanta lost ANOTHER team this summer and they still didn’t get as much guff from the Canadian press as Tampa Bay does on a regular basis for daring to even have a franchise.

Voodoo Five - South Florida Bulls SBN Blog
The Toughest Blog in America

by Jamie DeVriend on Aug 17, 2011 3:09 AM EDT reply actions  

It’s not because of the Stanley Cup that Canadians covet Lightning players like Stamkos and Vinny. Nashville fans hear all the time that obviously Shea Weber wants to play in BC/Detroit/anywhere but Nashville, obviously the team can’t keep good players, who would want to play/live there anyway? Winning or not winning doesn’t matter. It’s because we’re not like them.

"I'm a firm believer that in life, if you're happy then happy things will happen for you."--Bernie Parent
Part Predator, part Lightning.

by CAustin on Aug 17, 2011 8:59 AM EDT up reply actions  

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

"The static cling that brings Tampa Bay Lightning fans together", SB Nation's Bolts community is your place for news, commentary and camaraderie.

Pages

Posting Guidelines on Raw Charge

Lined-Up Update (2010 off-season)

Raw Charge apparel

Featured Poll

Poll
20th Anniversary Season poll: Favorite Tampa Bay Lightning logo?

  51 votes | Results

Raw Charge on the Web


Raw Charge on Tumblr

eXTReMe Tracker

Managing Editors

2011-03-06_12_small John Fontana

Imag0026_small Cassie McClellan

Writing Staff

Small Dani Toth

Ads_small Tina Robinson

Beardweekone_small Matt Amos

Photo_small Clark J Brooks

Snowman_in_net_small CAustin

Small shawndubstep